Skip to content

Asilomar Accords Data Collection: Standardized Shelter Definitions

A heartwarming moment of a cat cuddling a dog on green grass outdoors.

What the Asilomar Accords Standardized

The Asilomar accords definitions emerged from a 2004 convening at the Asilomar Conference Grounds in Pacific Grove, California, where leaders from across the animal sheltering field — ASPCA, HSUS, Maddie’s Fund, Best Friends, the National Animal Control Association, and academic shelter medicine programs — agreed on a common vocabulary for shelter outcomes and animal status. Before Asilomar, “no-kill” meant different things in different cities and grant applications were essentially incomparable.

The accords delivered three things that still anchor shelter data work today: a standardized nine-category outcome taxonomy, a four-tier health and behavior assessment classification, and a recommended monthly reporting template that aggregates cleanly to community and national levels. Adopting Asilomar is now table stakes for grant eligibility from major funders, accreditation by shelter associations, and inclusion in Best Friends Network’s national lifesaving dashboards.

This guide covers each component in operational detail, with notes on the most common implementation pitfalls when rescues first adopt the framework.

The Nine Outcome Categories

Every animal leaving your shelter exits through one of nine Asilomar-defined outcome categories. Adopted: placement in a permanent home directly from your organization. Transferred: sent to another agency for placement. Returned to owner: stray reclaimed by original guardian. Died in shelter: animal died in care, not by planned euthanasia. Lost in shelter: rare, but tracked for transparency.

The four euthanasia categories require careful classification. Owner-requested euthanasia (OE): surrender specifically for euthanasia of a terminally ill or severely aggressive animal — typically billed separately and not counted against LRR in some frameworks. Healthy euthanasia: euthanasia of an animal with no medical or behavioral barrier to placement; this is the metric the no-kill movement targets at zero. Treatable-manageable euthanasia: euthanasia of an animal with chronic but manageable conditions; this category should also shrink toward zero in mature systems. Untreatable euthanasia: euthanasia for irremediable physical suffering or documented dangerous-to-public behavior; ethically appropriate and excluded from no-kill rate calculations.

The Four Health and Behavior Tiers

Asilomar classifies every intake into one of four health-behavior tiers within five days of arrival, based on intake medical exam and initial behavioral observation. Healthy: no medical or behavioral conditions affecting placement. Treatable-rehabilitatable: a condition (medical or behavioral) likely to resolve fully with treatment available to a typical caring owner. Treatable-manageable: a chronic condition requiring lifelong management but compatible with quality of life and adoptability. Unhealthy and untreatable: irremediable suffering or dangerousness that would justify euthanasia.

The classification drives placement strategy and resource allocation. Healthy and treatable-rehabilitatable animals enter the standard adoption pipeline. Treatable-manageable animals route to specialized adopter pools, often through special-needs adoption programs and partnerships with breed-specific rescues. Unhealthy and untreatable animals receive humane euthanasia, with clear documentation supporting the classification.

How to Implement Asilomar Accords Definitions in Reporting

Modern shelter management software (PetPoint, ShelterBuddy, Chameleon, RescueGroups) builds Asilomar accords definitions directly into intake and outcome workflows. When staff classify an outcome, they’re selecting from the Asilomar-defined dropdown, and monthly reports generate automatically. If you’re not using software with Asilomar reporting built in, you’re spending three to five hours per month on manual reconciliation that should be automated.

Train every staff member and key volunteers on the classifications during onboarding. The most common implementation failure is inconsistent intake categorization — one shelter manager classifies a parvo-positive puppy as “treatable-rehabilitatable” while another classifies the same case as “treatable-manageable” or even “untreatable.” Build a one-page classification cheat sheet, review borderline cases at weekly operations meetings, and audit a sample of classifications quarterly for drift.

Monthly Reporting Template

The standard Asilomar monthly report includes opening inventory, intake (broken down by source: stray, surrender, transfer-in, born-in-care, return), and outcomes by category — all segmented by species (typically dog, cat, other) and ideally by age class. Closing inventory equals opening plus intake minus outcomes; this reconciliation is critical and exposes data quality issues immediately if numbers don’t balance.

Layer in length-of-stay metrics by outcome category for the full picture. A rescue might run a 94 percent live release rate with median adoption LOS of 18 days — a healthy combination. The same rescue running 94 percent LRR with median adoption LOS of 75 days has a hidden crowding problem that needs intervention.

Public Transparency and Donor Trust

Posting your Asilomar reports publicly on your website builds donor trust faster than any marketing campaign. Major foundations now require Asilomar-compliant reporting as a precondition for grant eligibility, and individual major donors increasingly ask to see two or three years of monthly transparency data before committing significant gifts. A dedicated “Our Numbers” or “Transparency” page with downloadable monthly PDFs is the operational standard.

The transparency forcing function also drives internal discipline. When the team knows October numbers will be online by November 10, the late-October push to find foster homes for long-stay animals happens differently. Public reporting is an operational lever, not just a reputational one.

National Data Aggregation: Shelter Animals Count

Shelter Animals Count is the national database of community animal sheltering statistics, founded as an industry-wide collaboration to aggregate Asilomar-compliant data across thousands of shelters into a single dataset. Submitting monthly through Shelter Animals Count puts your organization into national, state, and county-level dashboards that researchers, funders, and policy advocates use to identify trends and target resources.

Most shelter software platforms now support one-click export to Shelter Animals Count’s required format. The submission takes about 15 minutes per month once configured. The payoff: your organization becomes part of the data infrastructure that drives federal grant decisions, state policy advocacy, and national lifesaving strategy. There is no good operational reason a serious 501(c)(3) rescue should not be reporting to Shelter Animals Count.

Avoiding Common Classification Errors

Three classification errors recur across rescues new to Asilomar accords definitions. First, misclassifying transfers as adoptions — a transfer to a partner rescue is a transfer, even if you believe the partner will adopt the animal. Second, applying “owner-requested euthanasia” too broadly — OE applies only to surrenders where the explicit purpose is euthanasia of a specific animal, not to surrenders where the owner is willing to consent to euthanasia if necessary. Third, classifying behavioral euthanasia as “untreatable” without documented bite history, professional behavior assessment, and rehabilitation attempts on record.

Build a peer-review process: classifications above a certain threshold (any euthanasia, any reclassification of intake tier) require sign-off from a second senior staff member. The discipline pays off when an external auditor, donor, or accreditation reviewer audits your data — defensible classifications stand up to scrutiny in ways well-intentioned but undocumented ones do not. Pair this rigor with Best Friends Network reporting to maximize visibility for your transparency work.

Asilomar and the Evolution of Shelter Standards

The Asilomar accords definitions have evolved since 2004 as the sheltering field has matured. The original framework focused primarily on outcome classification; subsequent refinements have addressed intake categorization, the distinction between treatable-rehabilitatable and treatable-manageable, and the boundary between owner-requested and shelter-initiated euthanasia. The current operational standard is a living framework updated through periodic stakeholder convenings rather than a static 2004 document.

Maddie’s Fund, the Association for Animal Welfare Advancement, and Shelter Animals Count maintain working groups that periodically publish updated guidance on edge cases and emerging classification questions. Subscribe to their publications and revisit your internal classification training annually. Frameworks that ossify around 2004 definitions miss two decades of operational learning about how to count what matters.

Integrating Asilomar Data With Operational Decisions

Asilomar data isn’t just for external reporting — the same data should drive internal operational decisions. A monthly review that pairs intake categorization with outcome categorization exposes specific operational gaps: high treatable-manageable intake combined with high treatable-manageable euthanasia signals a placement-pipeline gap for chronic-condition animals (build special-needs adopter outreach and partner with breed-specific rescues for those cases). High healthy-intake combined with rising LOS signals an adoption-velocity problem that fee or marketing adjustments can address.

Building the data review into recurring operations meetings — monthly leadership review, quarterly board review, annual all-hands review — embeds Asilomar thinking into decision-making rather than treating it as a separate reporting workflow. Over a few years, this discipline produces the cultural shift that turns a well-meaning rescue into a high-performance lifesaving organization with measurable, defensible outcomes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do small rescues really need to implement full Asilomar reporting?

Yes, especially if you intend to pursue grant funding, accreditation, or partnerships with municipal shelters. Implementation effort is modest once shelter software is in place, and the credibility gains with donors and partners pay back the setup cost within a year. Small foster-based rescues with under 100 annual intakes can use lightweight tools but should still use Asilomar categories.

How do we classify a dog with severe heartworm at intake?

Heartworm-positive dogs are typically classified as treatable-rehabilitatable if early-stage and treatable-manageable if advanced. The classification informs your placement strategy and adoption fee structure. See the established heartworm-positive intake protocol for the medical workflow that pairs with the classification.

What’s the difference between Asilomar Accords and Shelter Animals Count?

Asilomar Accords is the standardized vocabulary (definitions and categories). Shelter Animals Count is the national database that uses Asilomar definitions to aggregate data across thousands of shelters. Think of Asilomar as the language and Shelter Animals Count as the conversation that uses it.

Can we publish Asilomar reports without identifying individual animals?

Yes — Asilomar reporting is fully aggregate. Monthly reports show category-level counts (5 healthy euthanasia, 12 adoptions, etc.) without exposing individual animal details. This makes public posting straightforward without privacy or operational concerns. Many rescues also publish year-over-year trend charts to show lifesaving progress over time.

Ready to adopt?

Find your perfect companion from shelters and rescues near you.

Browse Adoptable Pets

Related articles

Why Does My Chinchilla Nibble Me?
Pet Care

Why Does My Chinchilla Nibble Me?

Wondering why does my chinchilla nibble me? Learn what gentle nibbling means, from grooming and affection to attention-seeking, and how to respond kindly.

Why Does My Chinchilla Rub His Chin?
Pet Care

Why Does My Chinchilla Rub His Chin?

Wondering why does my chinchilla rub his chin? Learn about scent marking, territory, and the rare dental signs that mean it is time to call an exotics vet.

Why Does My Chinchilla Cough?
Pet Care

Why Does My Chinchilla Cough?

Worried why does my chinchilla cough? Learn the dust, respiratory, and dental causes of coughing and exactly when to call an exotics vet right away.